S&P 500, Nasdaq-100 & More: New Ways To Diversify on SGX

Hazelle

in Memos & Musings · 4 min read

Four new UCITS ETFs have just landed on SGX: XUS, EUS, XND and XWR.

There has been considerable discussion around these ETFs, particularly about their fees and tax treatment. How low are the fees? How much can investors potentially save? What about withholding tax?

These are all valid questions, and they matter.

However, investing is not simply about how much you pay in fees or taxes. A more important question is: what role do these four UCITS ETFs actually play in a portfolio?

If you add them to your portfolio, what are you really buying? What new opportunities could these ETFs offer? And how could they complement investments you already own to build a more diversified portfolio?

To answer these questions, it is useful to first understand what is actually underneath each of the four newly listed ETFs, before considering how their different exposures could potentially fit into a resilient portfolio.

What’s Actually Inside XUS, EUS, XND and XWR?

XUS ETF

The XUS ETF tracks the S&P 500 Index, which is made up of the 500 largest US companies.

However, these 500 companies are not equally weighted. They are weighted based on their free-float market capitalisation. In simple terms, the larger the company, the larger its weight in the index.

This becomes particularly apparent when looking at the ETF’s holdings. Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Alphabet and other mega-cap companies are among the largest positions. Together, the top 10 constituents account for close to 40% of the ETF.  

Xtrackers S&P 500 UCITS ETF (XUS)

On sector allocation, Information Technology and Communication Services make up more than 45% of the ETF, with many of the major companies involved in the AI theme sitting within these sectors.

Therefore, although it is called the S&P 500, the exposure is not spread equally across 500 companies. A relatively small number of mega-cap companies have a significant influence on the index.

This is NOT a flaw. It is simply the result of market-cap weighting. If the largest companies continue to outperform, this concentration can work well in an investor’s favour.

EUS ETF

What if an investor wants exposure to the same 500 companies but does not want the portfolio to be dominated by the largest names?

This is where the EUS ETF takes a different approach.

The EUS ETF also provides exposure to the same S&P 500 universe. However, instead of allowing the largest companies to dominate the index, each company is given roughly the same weight.

XUS vs EUS

The difference is significant. The top 10 holdings in EUS account for only around 3%, compared with close to 40% for XUS. The key difference comes down to one simple change in the index methodology: how the companies are weighted.

The sector exposure also changes significantly. Information Technology falls to around 15%, while Industrials, Financials and Healthcare make up a larger portion of the index. 

Because EUS is rebalanced quarterly, the weights are regularly brought back towards equal weighting. This means the index naturally trims companies that have become relatively larger and adds to companies that have become relatively smaller.

When comparing XUS and EUS, investors are therefore looking at two different ways of owning the same S&P 500 universe, with very different portfolio characteristics.

XND ETF

The XND ETF tracks the Nasdaq-100 Index, which consists of 100 of the largest non-financial companies listed on the Nasdaq Stock Exchange.

One important characteristic of the Nasdaq-100 is that Financials are essentially absent by design, while Information Technology makes up almost 60% of the index.

XND ETF

Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft, Micron, Amazon, AMD, Alphabet, Tesla and Broadcom are among the largest positions. The top 10 constituents account for more than 45% of the ETF.

There is also significant overlap between the top 10 constituents of XND and XUS.

From a portfolio-construction perspective, this means an investor who owns both XUS and XND may have a meaningful amount of overlapping exposure. If you own both ETFs, you have to think about how they complement the rest of your portfolio for broader diversification.

Instead, investors need to consider how these two ETFs complement the rest of their portfolio and whether the additional exposure is serving a specific purpose. 

XND vs XUS

XWR ETF

Finally, the XWR ETF tracks the MSCI World Index, which provides exposure to large- and mid-cap companies across developed markets.

Despite its name, the MSCI World Index does not include emerging markets such as China or India.

Source: Xtrackers by DWS

Looking at the top holdings, Nvidia, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Alphabet, Broadcom, Meta, Micron and Tesla still appear near the top.

The reason is that the US makes up the largest portion of the developed-market universe. As a result, the top 10 holdings account for close to 30% of the ETF.

XWR therefore provides broader geographical exposure compared with XUS, EUS and XND, with meaningful influence from the US.

XUS vs EUS vs XND vs XWR: What’s the Difference?

Putting the four ETFs side by side provides a useful way to understand their different roles.

How Can These Four ETFs Complement Your Portfolio?

Now that we understand what is inside these ETFs, the next question is how they could be used to create different exposures within a portfolio.

The first question investors should ask is: what do I already own?

Many investors tend to be concentrated in a particular market or sector. Some of the investors we spoke to during our in person events have portfolios that tend to be heavily weighted towards Singapore, particularly our three local banks.

On the other side of the spectrum, some investors may have portfolios almost entirely in the US markets, and that exposure often can also be particularly concentrated only around technology and AI names.

There is nothing inherently wrong with either approach. However, it may be worth considering how ETFs can complement these existing investments by introducing exposure to other sectors and markets.

Starting with the STI ETF

Consider a simplified scenario where an investor only owns an STI ETF.

Looking at the sector allocation, Financials, particularly the three local banks, make up more than half of the index.

STI Constituents

It is understandable why Singapore investors are comfortable owning these companies. We have well-established banks with strong regional businesses and long track records of paying dividends.

However, if a large part of a portfolio is already invested in Financials such as Singapore banks, what might be missing?

One potential gap is Technology.

This is where exposure to the Nasdaq-100, through an ETF such as XND, could play a complementary role. As discussed earlier, the Nasdaq-100 has very strong technology exposure, while financial companies are excluded from the index by design.

Therefore, putting an STI ETF and XND ETF side by side combines very different sector exposures. The STI ETF is heavily weighted towards Financials, while the XND ETF is heavily weighted towards Technology and other growth-oriented sectors.

This is how portfolio construction can be approached when using ETFs. It is not simply about identifying which ETF has the lowest costs or the most attractive tax treatment. More importantly, it is about understanding how different ETFs come together to provide complementary exposures and contribute to a diversified portfolio.

What Else Could You Add?

The diversification exercise does not have to stop there!

On top of exposure to Singapore banks through the STI and US technology through the Nasdaq-100, investors could consider what else might add another layer of diversification to the portfolio.

For example, Singapore REITs could introduce real estate and income exposure.

On the SGX, ETFs such as the Lion-Phillip S-REIT ETF (SGX: CLR) and the CSOP iEdge S-REIT Leaders Index ETF (SGX: SRT) provide exposure to a basket of Singapore-listed REITs. 

CLR ETF by Lion Global Investors

Source: Lion Global Investors

SRT ETF by CSOP Asset Management

Source: CSOP Asset Management

The interesting aspect of this combination is that the income exposure comes from different parts of the market.

Banks generate income from lending and other financial activities, while REITs derive income primarily from rents collected from their properties. Combining the two therefore brings together different sources of income and different types of assets within the portfolio.

This matters because different sectors and asset classes can respond differently to the same market environment.

Ultimately, the objective is to bring together different sources of income and Singapore market exposure rather than relying on only one part of the market.

Join our Telegram Channel to stay in the know with our investing insights.

Looking Beyond Singapore

Another area where many Singapore investors may have relatively little exposure is Asia Pacific outside Singapore.

One example of an ETF providing this exposure is the CSOP FTSE Asia Pacific Select Index ETF (SGX: LCS).

Source: CSOP Asset Management

This can provide exposure to Asian technology and semiconductor companies that may not be represented in US-focused ETFs such as XND or XUS, and even XWR, which does not include the emerging markets that LCS provides.

For investors considering AI and technology as a long-term theme, the opportunity does not necessarily have to be limited to Nvidia, Alphabet or other US mega-cap companies.

Companies across Asia also participate in the broader technology and semiconductor ecosystem.

Different ETFs, Different Roles

The XND ETF is just one way of adding US technology exposure.

For investors who want less concentration in technology, the S&P 500 through an ETF such as XUS provides broader exposure to large US companies across different sectors.

The XWR ETF takes this diversification one step further by providing exposure across developed markets beyond the US.

For investors who already have significant positions in individual US technology stocks, the EUS ETF offers another approach. Because it tracks the S&P 500 Equal Weight Index, exposure is spread more evenly across the 500 companies, reducing the concentration in the largest companies within the index.

This illustrates the broader idea behind portfolio construction.

Diversification does not simply mean buying more ETFs, because some ETFs may have significant overlapping exposure. Instead, diversification comes from understanding what each ETF actually provides, what you already own, and what each additional exposure adds to the overall portfolio.

Diversification Doesn’t Mean No Risk

While diversification can help spread exposure across markets and sectors, it does not eliminate risk completely.

Even after diversifying across different markets and sectors, there may be periods when certain parts of a portfolio still move in the same direction, particularly during periods of major market uncertainty.

Diversification can therefore help spread exposure, but it does not completely eliminate market risk.

For Singapore investors, currency risk is another factor to consider.

Although the four Xtrackers UCITS ETFs can be bought and sold in Singapore dollars on the SGX, the underlying investments are denominated in foreign currencies. Movements in those foreign currencies against the Singapore dollar can therefore affect investment returns.

What About Fees and Taxes?

The expense ratios of these Xtrackers UCITS ETFs are generally competitive, although the exact costs vary across the four ETFs.

Because these are UCITS ETFs domiciled in Ireland, the dividends received by the ETFs are generally subject to a 15% withholding tax rate, compared with the 30% rate that would typically apply to US-listed ETFs.

US estate tax also does not apply to these ETF holdings in the same way as it would for US-domiciled ETFs.

If you would like to understand the numbers in more detail, head over to our Instagram post here.

The Cheapest Way to Own S&P 500 in SGD by The Joyful Investors

Excerpt of The Joyful Investors’ Instagram Post on the four Xtrackers UCITS ETFs

Closing Thoughts

The Xtrackers UCITS ETFs discussed here offer a range of different exposures, from US large caps and the Nasdaq-100 to an equal-weighted S&P 500 and developed markets around the world.

Whether any of these exposures have a place in a portfolio ultimately depends on what an investor already owns and what they are trying to achieve.

Diversification is not simply about buying more ETFs. It is about understanding what each ETF actually gives you, where the overlaps are, and whether the additional exposure adds something different to the portfolio.

The key is therefore to look beyond the individual ETF and consider how it fits within the portfolio as a whole.

Stay in the know with the latest market insights

* indicates required

About Hazelle

Hazelle is the Chief Trainer and the Co-Founder of The Joyful Investors—a financial education firm committed to helping investors level up their portfolios and achieve financial independence (F.I.R.E). A first-class Accountancy graduate from Nanyang Technological University (NTU), she began her career in audit at one of the Big Four firms, where she honed her skills in financial analysis and business fundamentals.

To Hazelle, financial freedom isn’t just about retiring early—it’s about having the freedom to pursue what truly matters. She also heads TJ Academy, which runs the Moneyball Investors Playbook and Options Investors Playbook programs alongside other investor training workshops.

As an SGX Academy Trainer and SIAS Speaker, she actively supports financial education initiatives and regularly shares her insights on long-term investing, portfolio building, and market cycles.

Hazelle’s commitment to impacting the lives of investors extends beyond coaching sessions. She has spoken at prominent investment fairs internationally including MooFest, REITs Symposium and Invest Fair in Singapore and Malaysia, as well as at Baiduri Bank in Brunei. She has also conducted sharing sessions with investment clubs in local and overseas universities.

Important Information

This document is for information only and does not constitute an offer or solicitation nor be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell any of the investments mentioned. Neither The Joyful Investors Pte. Ltd. (“The Joyful Investors”) nor any of its officers or employees accepts any liability whatsoever for any loss arising from any use of this publication or its contents. The views expressed are solely the opinions of the author as of the date of this document and are subject to change based on market and other conditions. 

The information provided regarding any individual securities is not intended to be used to form any basis upon which an investment decision is to be made. The information contained in this document, including any data, projections and underlying assumptions are based upon certain assumptions and analysis of information available as at the date of this document and reflects prevailing conditions, all of which are accordingly subject to change at any time without notice and The Joyful Investors is under no obligation to notify you of any of these changes.

· · ·

Have you enjoyed this article? We’d be grateful if you would share this useful content to your friends who may benefit from it as well. 

Leave a Reply